armenian poster-thumb-520x296-38479

Considering the Holocaust, Will Israel Have the Balls to Recognize the Armenian Genocide?

Last May, Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin pledged he’d recognize the Armenian Genocide in the Knesset.  Rivlin’s a moderate in the Likud Party, but he’s been a hawk on the issue.  For five years, the Knesset has been debating commemorating the Ottoman Empire’s crimes.  In 2011, they finally made the discussions public.  So why is it so hard to acknowledge something that even Hitler supposedly did as early as 1939?  According to one translation, the scumbag put it this way: “Only thus shall we gain the living space (Lebensraum) which we need. Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?” So until now what’s kept Israel from acknowledging the disaster?  Quite simply, it would piss off Turkey.

Jews in other places around the world recognize the crime, and the Turks aren’t around to bully them into not.  The USC Shoah Foundation, which sports many high-value Jewish donors, is adding 400 recorded testimonies from survivors of the Armenian Genocide to its archives.  This is a major change for the foundation’s Institute, which has only focused on the Holocaust till now.  In 2007, the Anti-Defamation League recognized the WWI massacres.  The Zionist Organization of America also recognizes it.  But the ADL’s head Abraham Foxman did so only after pressure from inside his organization.  While Foxman wanted to protect Israel’s diplomatic position, his own organization pressured him to face the facts.  Inside Israel, now that Turkey’s on the outs with Jerusalem, what could possibly justify continuing this ridiculous policy?

Azerbaijan.  Despite whatever denials the government here in Israel cooks up, the security asset the Azeris are in the fight against Iran is tremendous.  Israel might use Azerbaijan as a staging ground to attack nuclear sites, so reports say, so now denying the Armenian Genocide seems as important as ever.  On April 6th, an Azerbaijani news outlet got to interview the country’s ambassador from Israel.  What he said was revealing:

Question: Recently, the committee of the Knesset has discussed so called “Armenian genocide.” Will this issue come to the agenda of the Israeli parliament?
Ambassador Michael Lotem: The committee will discuss, but I think it will not go beyond. This issue should be kept to historians, not dealt by the politicians.

No matter how many meetings there are in the Knesset, Israel’s Foreign Ministry still seems to be revealing the country’s intent.  Any Knesset meeting on the subject is a publicity stunt aimed at scaring the Turks.  It’s not serious.  It’s embarrassing as a country so intent on highlighting the devastation of the Holocaust that its leaders are apathetic to the idea of recognizing other crimes.  Benjamin Netanyahu has used the Holocaust as a point of comparison to Iran’s intent regarding Israel’s Jews, so what good could it possibly do to diminish another genocide and risk diluting the significance of the Holocaust in the eyes of the world?

Turkey still refuses to recognize the magnitude or viciousness of the slaughter, arguing the numbers of those killed and the circumstances – battle as opposed to systematic murder.  But a wave of European countries do not just recognize the event but criminalize denying it.  On April 9th, it was reported the head of the Slovakian Supreme Court would have any Turkish official prosecuted if he dared deny the genocide on Slovakian soil.  France pissed off Turkey several year ago when it passed its own version of the law.  France’s statute was ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court there, but the attitude toward the event is clearly on equal terms to how countries treat denial of the Holocaust.  Europe is awash with these laws.  Germany is the most famous for it, but in other countries the statutes exist: Austria, France, Poland and Portugal.  Spain is more lenient about denial per se, but specifically prosecutes justifying the Holocaust.  Israel has its laws outlawing Holocaust denial, but hasn’t even brought itself to acknowledge the mere happening of the Armenian tragedy.

Recognizing it will deepen Israel’s relationship with Turkey’s rivals: Greece and Cyprus.  Turkey usually threatens consequences for diplomatic ties if another country recognizes the genocide.  That threat means little these days in Jerusalem.  Without leverage on Israel, the Jewish voice on the matter will weigh heavy against Turkey in the court of international opinion.  Whatever problems Israel has diplomatically, its authority on genocide issues and its intimate connection to the Holocaust make the Jewish point of view extremely important to advocates of genocide prevention and recognition (see Armenia, Rwanda, Darfur).

Otniel Schneller, a member of the parliament, rolled out the identical argument for avoiding the issue as others had in the past, saying “Sometimes our desire to be right and moral overcomes our desire to exist, which is in the interest of the entire country.”  But it’s more paranoid than proven that Turkey or Azerbaijan could have such a devastating effect on Israeli security.  Turkey’s relationship has gone to crap with Israel, Syria and Iraq over the last several years, leaving it with little leeway for its own foreign policy in the region and thus little to threaten Israel with.  Regarding Israel, the Jewish state lets other countries dictate its talk in the strangest ways, and the state is only undermining its assertiveness letting pressure from a non-ally, Turkey, bully the Jewish state into avoiding a simple moral statement.  Turkey and Azerbaijan still need Israel as an ally against Iran; not just the other way around.  Not acknowledging Jewish sovereignty on the issue is not merely impotent, but hits at the ‘galus’ mentality.

Recognizing the “Forgotten Holocaust” this year is a promise of Rivlin’s, but he’ll have to put his money where his mouth is to end this embarrassing situation.  Rivlin and the entire Knesset will soon get their shot.  It’s disgraceful it’s taken so long, but perhaps this year the ball will drop.

Gedalyah Reback is a Master’s Student at Hebrew University in Middle East Studies.  He blogs at